The path to true love is long and twisty for Natalie Simmons (Lenz). Recently fired from her broadcasting job in San Francisco, Natalie returns to her Oregon to assist her mom (Mary-Margaret Humes) with the town’s annual Valentine’s Festival. Although Natalie is officially engaged, she’s thrown for a big loop when she reconnects with kind, handsome Zach Williams (Macfarlane), the guy who broke her heart—and their engagement—10 years ago.